I recently bought the 4th addition to my collection of force fx lightsabers by adding my Mace Windu, I am not sure if it is AOTC or ROTS. If someone can tell me the differences i'd appreciate it. Whichever it is though my reveiw for it is quite simple. I am quite impressed with the hilt, the electrum look is great and the grip is outstanding. I have heard rumors of muffled sounds in the Mace but mine does not have that problem, the sound is rich and sharp. On the flip side of the coin I am not impressed with the blade color. The fact it is not a true purple blade puts a damper on things. The blue and red led lights make a close to royal purple, but not quite, not to mention they leave a pink stripe all the way down the blade. There is also spotting in the blade, moreso than others I have. Over all I give this saber a 7 1/2 of 10.