Well, I finally picked up my luke ROTJ saber today from borders and I have to say I am absolutely impressed with this saber.
First of all, the blade is so awesome. The blade on my luke does not even have the black bands or splotches and it just looks like the real deal. The blade is so bright that the minute you power down it blinds you for a couple seconds. The green is very unique and is my favorite. There also weren't any scratches on my blade.
Second, the sounds are fantastic! It sounds realistic and it even beats the ani sounds by a hair. They are very crisp and they definately get your attention.
Third, the hilt is good, but it is not my favorite. I like the shiny crome look on the ani better. However, the hilt is very solid and light. This saber is the best for doing twirls with. You can easily do the behind the back spin move that anakin does in ROTS. The fat neck doesn't bother me one bit. Another thing about the hilt on my luke is that the D-ring is relatively loose and it makes clinging noises when doing spins. This however, doesn't really bother me that much. It is awesome to own a piece of the original trilogy. Green is the best!!! :)