Wavering between 9 and 10. My favorite Star Wars movie. I gave it a 9, only because there are a couple things I would have liked a little more of. Like the Jedi purge in them temple, a couple of the cut scenes. But it's nearly perfect.
I mean come on, Anakin vs Obi-Wan, Mace vs Sidious, Dooku vs Anakin & Obi-Wan, and Yoda vs Emperor Palpatine. So many legendary battles, it's like they were giving us just about every thing we wanted to see through out the whole Star Wars movies. I'm not ashamed to admit this, but I really teared up when I saw the movie in the theater. The scene where the Clone Troopers were executing Order 66, killing their Jedi commanders, got me choked up as did the ending when Padme had died, Anakin was overseeing the Death Star creation now as Darth Vader (in the suit), and Luke and Leia's fate really got to me. In fact, after seeing RotS, the wedding scene and the scene were Padme reveals her feelings for Anakin in AotC get me choked up now because of what becomes of them in RotS.
Randy