I'm curious on opinions, too. Personally, I've really enjoyed all the recent gen of Star Wars films on the whole, but I (pleasingly, surprisingly) enjoyed Rogue One the most - I found it really engaging and compelling, visually top notch and exciting, and, for me, it pulled off both doing new stuff that still felt like it belonged in the Star Wars universe and storyline AND channeling the spirit of the original trilogy and giving me a warm fuzzy, grinny nostalgia hit, esp the way it segued into ANH really nicely (aside from the minor niggle that the plans weren't beamed to the Tantive IV as Vader said in ANH, but I can give that a pass lol). I thought I'd enjoy it as reasonable filler between the main films, but found it way way better than I expected